I watched a movie tonight, one of these somewhat ridiculous post-Nora Ephron romantic comedies in which the main obstacle to the characters getting together is that they feel a little bit nervous about getting together. This one involved several different pairings of people in various states of meeting/dating/coupling/cheating etc, and one of the things I noticed is that all of the characters talked constantly about how "confused" they were. Aside from, obviously, it being a sign of very bad writing, it got me thinking about how often I have heard people talk about being "confused" in their relationships. And what a load of shit I think it is.
I admit, I am pretty harsh with people, and I have an unfortunate tendency to be even more harsh with them when they are feeling at their most vulnerable. But I can't stand the theatre of confusion. Being "confused" about a relationship is one of many claims that I think is, pretty much always, a lie.
So here is my guide to sorting out your confusion, so that you can avoid your own life becoming a poorly written romantic comedy.
First and foremost: "confusion" is a sign of dishonesty. I'm cracking that code for you right here and now. The only reason you are "confused" is either because you are being manipulated or because you are trying to manipulate someone else--- that part is key, because this mostly does not happen by accident. Ninety percent of the time someone tells you that they are confused, it is because
they are trying to confuse you.
It's actually kind of brilliant. I have gotten a lot of mileage out of it, myself.
A dude who tells you he is confused is telling you that he wants to fuck you, maybe even wants to fuck you a lot, but he is with his girlfriend and is not going to leave his girlfriend. And he knows that you will not fuck him unless you think maybe he might accidentally leave her in a fit of confusion. He won't. He's not confused. He knows he won't leave her. You, in turn, now feel confused, but your confusion is not a sign of you having feelings that are new and surprising and hard to understand: you confusion comes from the fact that someone you like a lot is lying to you.
And that is genuinely confusing, because as people we are naturally compelled to believe what we are told. It is why movies and plays and books are so powerful: because we can't tell the difference between what is real and what isn't. Obviously we CAN tell the difference, with some time and effort, but physically, emotionally we never learn one thing from the other. We respond to everything we see and hear as though it is real. Our brains, at least our immediate, animal brains, never quite learn to accommodate the fact that something you are told might not be true.
But that effect is short. For someone to keep you "confused" for any length of time, you have to play along. Save yourself a lot of pain by learning to spot this giant red flag. When you find yourself being "confused" you are either being lied to or you are lying. Either he is telling you he will leave his girl, or you are telling yourself he might.
And that is another thing I can settle right here on this page:
HE WON'T LEAVE HIS GIRLFRIEND FOR YOU. Never. This has never happened in the history of relationships. I swear to God's holy anus, it never has.
Now, she may find out he is screwing around with you, and then if we're all lucky she will dump his cowardly ass, and then he will crawl over to your apartment claiming that he left her for you. But he didn't. No dude has ever had the guts to leave his girlfriend/fiance/wife for another woman. Ever. Even if he "confessed" to her about his cheating, he did it because he knew he was going to get caught, and he was trying to score all the points he could. Probably by confessing and telling her how confused he was. Which usually works, by the way. A man in a long term relationship can get a lot of extra pussy by skillfully and repeatedly playing the confusion card.
The thing is, people really don't get confused about how they feel. What they are confused about is how to explain what they feel in a way that makes them sound good. To most people it sounds pretty crappy to say "well, yes, I have a boyfriend, but I really wanted to give this other man a try to see if he would be better, so I went and did that." Or "Yes, he is engaged, but I am lonely and I think he's hot, so I fucked him and I would like to do it again." Those are ugly things to say. (unless you are me, in which case I love you for saying them.) But being confused feels softer. It feels almost tragic. And you are the tragic hero, the victim of a circumstance bigger than you can manage.
I have a lot of sympathy-- encouragement, even--- for people making bad choices and nasty mistakes. But I don't have any soft spots for people claiming they didn't know what they were doing. Of course, as an arrogant bastard myself, I have never understood why people prefer to claim stupidity over selfishness. Everyone is selfish and everyone understands--- you don't get angry at your friends for cheating unless you are a victim. But you don't hear a lot of people say "that dude is stupid" with a tone of warm understanding.
Conflicted, yes. I give you conflicted. Ambivalent, torn, and many other words you could find in a thesaurus. Probably "confused" would even be in there, but that one is special. It is different. I am way down with people who are conflicted and don't know what the right thing to do is. But the words people use are far more specific than we usually give credit for. And "confused" is a call word for some dark shit going down somewhere. I've heard people say they were conflicted, and be able to tell why and what they are trying to choose between. But I have never met anyone who said "I'm just so confused" who later went on to figure out what they were confused about and take appropriate action. People who are confused remain confused for as long as it takes for someone ELSE to make the important decisions for them.
I do believe it is possible to be really confused by relationships. I am just saying that it doesn't happen unless someone in the mix is being crafty.
So, add it to the list of red flag words. Confused.
(other new additions to the list of red flag words: "Venomous," "Smashed," and "Pregnant")